Home
/
Expert opinions
/
Analysis reports
/

Is a history of accidents a dealbreaker for your classic ride?

Classic Toyota FJ62: Restored Beauty or Resale Nightmare? | Assessing Accident History

By

Mohammed Aziz

Apr 12, 2025, 07:31 AM

Edited By

Maya Patel

Updated

Apr 16, 2025, 06:51 PM

2 minutes of reading

A vintage 1989 Toyota FJ62 showcasing its unique character post-accidents, parked against a scenic backdrop.

A 1989 Toyota FJ62 is stirring debate in restoration circles as potential buyers grapple with its history of six accidents. The Carfax report raises concerns about whether nostalgia can overcome the truck's troubled past, especially in today's competitive classic vehicle market.

The Controversy Unfolds

With five accidents documented in the early 1990s and one more in 2013, prospective owners are questioning the vehicle's worth. While some see a worthwhile project, others express hesitation. In a user board post, one enthusiast noted, "Who gives a crap what happened 20 years ago as long as the title is clean?" Nonetheless, many remain cautious about the implications of past damage.

Community Insights:

Amid the discussions, notable opinions emerged:

  • Skepticism About Selling on BaT: A strong sentiment against using Bring a Trailer (BaT) has surfaced. Comments warn buyers to think twice about selling a vehicle with a messy Carfax. "Buyer beware," stressed one commenter.

  • Restoration Realities: To successfully flip the truck, prospective sellers should ensure it’s restored by a reputable shop. "Final price will be much lower unless restored by a well-regarded shop," was echoed by several.

  • Verification is Key: Discussions indicate that buyers want proof of the frame’s condition. As one commenter stated, "To make any sale easier, I want proof that this thing's solid."

Sentiments in the Community

The community's response to the FJ62's accident history varies:

  • Optimism for Restoration: Some enthusiasts see potential in revitalizing the truck, especially if proper documentation is provided.

  • Worries About Resale Value: Many view the accident history as a deterrent for future buyers.

  • Curiosity for Verification Methods: The need for confirmation about the vehicle's state has become a hot topic, as seen in the call for thorough documentation.

"If the frame is straight and you're really swapping out the panels, it doesn’t matter what happened back then," one user argued, emphasizing restoration over history.

Key Points to Consider

  • βš–οΈ Restoration Quality Matters: Having documented proof enhances perceived value amongst potential buyers.

  • 🚩 Accident History Raises Questions: The truck’s past could hinder resale opportunities.

  • 🀝 Documentation Can Build Trust: Solid evidence of restoration will ease buyer concerns.

As classic car enthusiasts continue to weigh the pros and cons, the FJ62 serves as a case study in the complexities of selling vintage vehicles. Successful restoration combined with thorough evidence may captivate buyers eager to invest in a piece of automotive history. For insights into classic vehicle valuation, enthusiasts may want to check Hemmings for expert tips.