New Lens Debate | Old vs. New 24-70 f/2.8 SII Price Drop Sparks User Conversations
Edited By
Elena Ivanova
As Nikon enthusiasts discuss recent discounts on the older 24-70 f/2.8 lens version, tensions rise over whether to invest in the newer Mark II. With a $500 reduction for the first generation, opinions are split.
A Pricey Dilemma
In September 2026, discussions on photography forums reveal a mixed sentiment among users considering which lens to buy. The older version's price drop to around $2,000 has many questioning the value of the newer, lighter alternative.
"The only problem with M2 is that it has ruined other zooms for me" one commenter noted, highlighting the impact of the upgrade on their experience.
Key Themes from the User Discussions
Price Sensitivity: Many users favor the first generation due to lower costs, stating that image quality differences aren't substantial enough to justify an upgrade.
Weight Considerations: Event photographers emphasize the lighter weight of the second generation, which is a significant advantage during long shoots.
User Experience: Comments reflect strong loyalty to the first generation, with users citing it as a "stellar lens" for professional work, and others mentioning difficulty in selling due to market saturation.
Representative Quotes
"If you don’t need internal zoom or the slightly lighter weight, I would recommend going with Gen 1."
"For wedding photography, I would get the best one Ver II for sure."
User Sentiment: Mixed Feelings
The conversation displays diverse perspectives, with price-conscious photographers leaning towards the original while others vouch for the newer version's enhancements. Some even hint at future generations, suggesting hesitance in final decisions.
Takeaways
✔ Price Trends: Old version currently sells for $1,200-2,000, making it a competitive choice.
✔ Market Insights: The market is flooded with Gen 1 options, complicating resale prospects.
✔ User Preferences: "I got first gen used for $1,100. Stellar lens for my pro work" – one user confirmed, emphasizing its cost-effectiveness.
Culmination
As discussions continue, it appears that while the second generation reaches more buyers, the first generation's steep discount provides an attractive alternative for budget-conscious photographers. Will the new version ultimately prove its worth, or will the older one remain a favorite in professional circles? Time will tell.
What's on the Horizon
Experts predict that as more photographers weigh their options, sales for the first generation lens could spike, potentially reaching up to 30% of current buyers. With big discounts and a strong reputation, many may opt for Gen 1 over the enhancements of the newer model. On the other hand, if Nikon can successfully leverage positive reviews surrounding the Gen II’s performance, they may see a gradual increase in its adoption, possibly cornering about 60% of the market within the next year. Therefore, discerning buyers will likely make choices that reflect their immediate needs versus long-term investments, creating a rich environment for both models in an already competitive market.
A Lens for All Seasons
Thinking back to the transition from film to digital, many enthusiasts clung to their trusted gear, much like these present lens discussions. Early adopters of digital cameras faced similar dilemmas of cost versus benefit, often sticking with reliable equipment during rapid changes in technology. In both instances, users prioritize familiarity and practicality over flashy advancements, highlighting a common thread in the evolution of photography tools: even with progress, the tried-and-true often holds its ground.